10 Best Quesadilla Maker 2020 – Reviews and Guide

All of us, especially moms, want to provide our family with homemade and delicious dishes every day. A lot of times, we’re too busy at work or doing other household chores that we do not have much time to spend in the kitchen.

Well, this is the perfect time to make quesadillas! Quesadilla is a tortilla that is filled with cheese, meat, beans, and spices.

To do this, you need to get the best quesadilla maker. I am sure you’ve heard of it before. Many people pronounce it as a “casadia maker” and search for it on the internet, but “casadia maker” is not the right word. Anyway, here is our take on the top quesadilla maker review!

Our Best Quesadilla Maker Reviews 

Here are the top ten models that you should consider purchasing. We handpicked each product and listed their pros and cons. Choose one that will fit your preferences.

1. Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker 

You will always find this Hamilton 25409 on top of quesadilla makers reviews because of how good it is. You just need to choose your desired fillings, load it up, wait for a few minutes and you have a delicious Mexican treat!

Hamilton designed this model with ease of use in mind. The product comes with two lights, one to indicate that the machine is heating up, and the other one to indicate that your quesadilla is ready to be eaten.

For easy cleaning and releasing, the model features a non-stick cooking dish that has a sleek, black finish. On top of that, you also get a locking lid to give the quesadillas a firm structure. Also, it keeps everything in place and prevents spillage.

The inner linings in this model have a nice height to them that allows you to separate each wedge without any effort. You will also notice that the edges come with sealing rings to prevent your ingredients from leaking and oozing out.

In terms of capacity, it is enough to feed a small family. And in one batch, you can make 6 delicious quesadillas. Also, it only takes about five minutes to cook them.

We also love how compact this model is. It can fit small spaces since you can store it upright. You also get a bonus list of recipes that you can try. Of course, you can just use whatever leftover meat and cheese you have in the fridge, and you’re good to go.

Pros

  • Comes at an affordable price
  • Easy to clean, thanks to the nonstick interior
  • Convenient light indicators
  • Very easy to use

Cons

  • Not enough capacity for a lot of people

2. George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker

This quesadilla maker form George Foreman really stands out from the crowd. Its cherry red and modern look is a perfect addition to your kitchen appliances, and we’re sure that it will be one of your most-used gadgets.

This model is one of the few quesadilla makers with removable plates. Plus,this 10-inch quesadilla maker has also one of the largest capacities in the quesadilla making game!

The plate is divided into six large wedges that will satisfy each member of the family’s appetite. In as quick as three minutes, your mouth-watering quesadillas are ready to be served!

The dip-dish pockets of this quesadilla maker will allow you to use a lot of ingredients as filling like meat and sausages. It comes with a light indicator that will tell you once it reached the perfect temperature to place your tortillas and fillings.

Aside from the ease of use, we also liked how easy it is to clean. It is one of the few quesadilla makers in the market. You can just pop it right out of the machine for soft brushing.

On top of that, the surface of this model is created with a non-stick coating. The raised outer ridge will help keep the filling inside the tortillas.

One thing you have to remember when using this model is that it can be too hot, especially with constant use. So, be sure to keep it out of reach for your little ones. Also, some users reported that it does not have perfect heat distribution.

Pros

  • Capacity is huge
  • Efortless to keep clean
  • You can put a lot of filling, thanks to the deep-dish plates
  • Removable plates

Cons

  • The plates can get too hot
  • Uneven heat distribution

3. Dash DMG8100RD 8” Express Electric Round Griddle

Dash is a brand that is well known to provide easy-to-use and durable kitchen appliances. Their goal is to help people improve their health and wellness. Quesadillas are not the healthiest, but this round griddle will help us create delicious quesadillas.

Why is this product worth buying? Well, it does not only make quesadillas, but you can also use it to make grilled cheese, omelets, cookies, burgers, and pancakes without the need for multiple pots and pans! What more can you ask for?

We love how compact and portable this model is. It only weighs 3 pounds so you can bring it anywhere you like. It is the perfect companion if you’re always in a rush to cook breakfast or lunch for work or school.

Also, if you’re living in a dorm or just starting to buy your own kitchen appliances, this is the perfect appliance. It is very multifunctional, and anyone can use it.

To operate this little gadget, you just need to plug it in and wait for a few minutes until the indicator light turns off. This is the perfect time to put your tortillas and filling into it!

Both surfaces are non-stick and PFOA-free. They are very easy to clean and use, and you don’t have to worry about food sticking to it. You will also get even cook anytime you use it.

Pros

  • Compact and lightweight
  • It is very multi functional
  • Nonstick interior is easy to clean
  • Convenient light indicators
  • Very easy to use, perfect for busy moms

Cons

  • May fall short in terms of capacity
  • Does not divide the quesadillas

4. Black & Decker Quesadilla Maker

Dash DMG8100AQ

A lot of parents struggle with making delicious meals for their kids because of how busy they are. Each model mentioned in this review will help you make quick, easy-to-do quesadillas, but this particular quesadilla maker from Black & Decker will impress you more.

In less than 5 minutes, you and your children can enjoy some mouth-watering, cheesy and savory quesadillas! This is also the perfect quesadilla maker for large parties where you need to make batches after batches.

The model comes with 8-inch cooking plates. This is not the largest capacity in the market, but you can create pretty thick quesadillas. It features a deep-dish pan so you can be generous and put a lot of fillings. You can put beans, leftover carne asada, and some cheese for that authentic Mexican flavor.

It also comes with six wedge pockets and a non-stick coating cooking plate. You are sure to get six evenly cooked quesadillas in a few minutes that you can just pop right out of the maker!

And the raised press and seal lines help to keep the fillings inside each quesadilla. No need to worry about any mess. Like any other models in this review, you get two light indicators. You just need to put your tortilla and fillings in, close the lid and wait for the light to go green.

Since the surface is non-stick, you don’t have to worry about food sticking into it. Also, it makes it very easy to clean!

Pros

  • Comes with deep dish cooking plates
  • Easy to clean
  • Convenient light indicators
  • Cooks quesadillas quickly

Cons

  • Can only make 8-inch quesadillas

5. Nostalgia Taco Tuesday Deluxe 10-Inch 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker with Extra Stuffing Latch 

Nostalgia

Well, this model is not really a taco maker but a quesadilla maker, and it’s a good one. This model from Nostalgia is a 10-inch quesadilla maker. If 10-inch is too much for you, which we doubt, there is also an 8-inch version that you can choose.

This red, slim, and compact quesadilla maker will fit anywhere in the kitchen. It’s very lightweight, not more than 5 pounds, so you can bring it anywhere like your upcoming potluck party so anyone can enjoy your fresh and hot cheesy quesadillas.

The cooking plate allows you to create 6 wedges of quesadillas in one batch. This model takes pride in their extra stuffing latch. What does that mean? Well, the two-position latch on the lid adjusts to allow for thin or thick stuffed quesadillas. No need to limit yourself to a few spoonfuls of cheese stuffing!

Like the other models on this list, it also is very easy to cook your quesadillas. It comes with two indicator lights to let you know once it reaches the perfect heat and once your quesadillas are ready to be served.

And the model also comes with a non-stick surface that makes it easy to release the quesadillas from the plates. Of course, it also makes the cleaning a breeze. Just be careful when using your forks or tongs because the surface can be easily dented.

Pros

  • Convenient two position latch
  • Lightweight and compact
  • Convenient light indicators
  • Very easy to maintain

Cons

  • The coating is easily dented

6. Elite Cuisine EQD-118 Maxi-Matic 11" Non-Stick Quesadilla Maker

Elite Cuisine EQD-118

This product from Elite Cuisine is the best quesadilla maker for those who wish to create large quesadillas. It can cook up to 11-inch quesadillas almost instantly, perfect for your neighborhood fiesta. This is a really nice feature that is hard to find in other quesadilla makers out there.

One or two pieces is enough to make anyone’s tummy full. If you need to feed a lot of people, you don’t have to worry about coming short. It only takes about 4 to 5 minutes to cook 1 batch of large quesadillas so you can create a lot of batches in half an hour.

Like every kitchen appliance, this model has its own disadvantages. Although you can make large quesadillas, you cannot really add too much filling to them. A nice cooking plate depth is crucial in any quesadilla makers to be able to come up with a chewy, savory filling that everyone is looking for.

In terms of operation, this model is very easy to use. It features two light indicators. One will indicate that the model is plugged in and working. The other one will indicate that the optimum heat is reached and will also tell you if your quesadilla is ready.

Unlike other products, this model comes with a drainage rim that will collect any excess grease.

Pros

  • Offers an 11-inch capacity, much larger than average
  • Features a drainage rim to collect excess grease
  • Easy to use, thanks to the two light indicators
  • Comes with a locking latch to prevent spilling

Cons

  • Thin plates allow only adding a few fillings

7. Santa Fe Quesadilla Maker 

Santa Fe

This product has been around in the market for 15 years, and we think it only means that we can rely on and trust this model. No wonder why a lot of cooking enthusiasts and homeowners have been singing its praises.

If you don’t mind spending quite a bit of money in your quesadilla make, then you might like this one from Sante Fe. It is one of the most expensive models on this list, but you will like how it performs.

Also, this 12-inch quesadilla maker comes in a bright red color and will surely catch everyone’s attention. You will be impressed as to how quickly it heats up. What’s more, it will only take it 4 to 5 minutes to cook your quesadillas!

The large capacity of 12 inches is what makes this model land on top of every quesadilla makers reviews. You only need a piece or two of your quesadillas, and you’re good to go.

And you get non-stick, heavy-duty cooking plates that will make it easy to clean any sticky residue. What’s more, it also comes with a drip tray to keep all the mess inside the machine. No need to worry about making a mess on your countertop!

You also get two indicator lights to make cooking easier. And you don’t have to open the machine to check if your quesadilla is ready because the machine will do it for you.

Pros

  • Largest capacity in the market
  • Convenient drip tray
  • Comes with light indicators
  • Non stick interior

Cons

  • Expensive and heavy

8. Brentwood TS-120 Quesadilla Maker

Santa Fe QM2R 900

For over 25 years, Brentwood has provided the market with top of the line kitchen appliance, and this quesadilla maker is one of their pride and joy. Will it live up to our expectations? Let’s find out!

Even heat distribution is key to achieve perfectly cooked quesadillas. You will be impressed by how good this quesadilla maker performs, thanks to its built-in temperature control. Say goodbye to burnt and cold quesadillas! Its compact design is one of the reasons why a lot of homeowners love it.

And it does not take up a large space in your kitchen, and you can just store it even in the tight spaces.

Since it is compact, we cannot expect too much from its capacity. Nevertheless, you can make 8 to 9-inch quesadillas in just a few minutes. The inner plates will divide your quesadillas into 6 even pieces and will ensure that no filling will leak or ooze out.

If you’re like me, I get too excited about adding my ingredients, and it turns out I have used more than enough. Unfortunately, it might result in a lot of mess. Well, this product comes with a removable drip tray just for that. No need to worry about creating a huge mess in the kitchen because it will collect it for you.

Aside from the removable drip tray, the cooking plates in this model are also non-stick. It makes it very easy to clean and use.

Pros

  • Creates evenly cooked quesadillas
  • Very compact and lightweight
  • Comes with light indicators
  • Effortless to use and clean

Cons

  • Small Capacity

9. El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker 

El Paso 10023

This quesadilla maker from El Paso has a cute design that really gives you Mexican vibes. The handle is shaped like chili, and the body is of red color. Surely, your children will love making quesadillas with you. This model comes with a maximum tortilla size of 10 inches.

It’s enough to feed the whole family, and it is the perfect tool to make game day appetizers. The cooking plates also have a nice depth to them, so you can incorporate quite a lot of fillings.

If ever you put too much grease, do not worry. It comes with a built-in reservoir to collect any grease, melted cheese, and sauce that is produced when cooking your quesadillas. Your countertop will stay clean even if you use it all day!

The model also features a non-stick surface. It makes cleaning very easy, and you are that your quesadillas will be very easy to pop out after cooking. Plus, you don’t have to use any oil!

Inside, you will notice that the model consists of 6 wedges. It will do a good job of dividing your quesadillas evenly, but do not expect it to cut them out for you. For operation, it comes with light indicators that will tell you when you’re done preheating and when the quesadillas are ready to be eaten.

Pros

  • Very easy to use, you just put all your ingredients and wait
  • The non-stick interior makes it easy to clean
  • Comes with two light indictors
  • Very large capacity; can make 10-inch quesadillas
  • Built-in reservoir  to collect all the mess

Cons

  • The latch is flimsy
  • Weighs heavy

10. BELLA (13506) 8-inch Quesadilla Maker with Non-Stick Plates

BELLA (13506)

The last model in our list is from Bella, and it has a lot of resemblance with the El Paso quesadilla maker. They are, however, different in many ways.

Bella created this model with small kitchens and pantries in mind. See, the product very small and weighs less than 3 pounds! If you have very little space in your apartment or condo, this quesadilla maker would be a great purchase since you can also cook other dishes with it. Pancakes, crepes, and pizzadillas are just a few.

Although if you are a dedicated quesadilla enthusiast, you might want to choose another product on this list. See, it can only make 8-inch quesadillas. Although, we must say that this capacity is not too far with the average quesadilla makers.

And the non-stick plates in this model will make it easy to clean up every after use. Since it is non-stick, you don’t really need to use oil. But if you do and you used too much, the built-in drip tray will catch all the mess for you!

Like most models, you get six evenly divided quesadilla wedges with this product. Although, you still need to use a knife or pizza cutter since the product does not cut it for you.

You can cook your quesadillas in just a few minutes. Plus, it features two light indicators to tell you if your quesadillas are done.

Pros

  • Very lightweight and compact
  • Convenient light indicators
  • Non-stick surfaces
  • Drip  tray to collect any mess

Cons

  • Small capacity

What Makes the Right Quesadilla Maker? 

Quesadilla makers are not created the same. They carry a lot of different features and specifications, which can be overwhelming to consumers. We will help you choose the best quesadilla maker by taking into account these few points.

Size 

Size is one of the most important factors to be considered when looking for the best quesadilla maker. First, think of the size of your kitchen and the area you wish to store your quesadilla maker. Make sure it will fit. You want a model that will save you some space.

Capacity

Next to size is capacity. How many quesadillas do you plan to make? How many people will you be serving? If you have a large family, it’s important to look for a quesadilla maker that can make ample quesadillas in one batch so you can also save time.

Weight

The right quesadilla for you should be lightweight yet durable at the same time. It should be easy to bring around anywhere so you can enjoy making quesadillas anytime and anywhere you want.

Heat Distribution

Nothing is worse than having a quesadilla that is not baked properly. You want your quesadilla to be perfectly cooked all the way through. And you want the heat to be distributed evenly so that all pieces are cooked the same. Look for models that offer heat distribution.

Depth

Depth is another factor to think about in purchasing your quesadilla maker. How deep your cooking plates are will determine the thinness and thickness of the quesadillas. Well, this depends on your taste.

If you want some thick quesadillas, choose a model with deep cooking plates. Other than this, you can also stuff more ingredients with deep-dish quesadilla makers than the thin ones, making the end result more relishing, filling, and delicious.

Material and Construction

In any appliance, durability is key in determining if a product is worth the investment or not. You want your appliance to last you for decades or for a few years, at least. Just like in choosing a quesadilla maker, you want a durable, heavy-duty construction.

The materials used in creating the model will tell you how sturdy and strong it will be and will help give you an idea of how good the heat distribution is. Look for models made with stainless steel or iron. Both will give you superb quality without sacrificing the taste.

Also, try to look for a non-stick coating. This will help you make better quality quesadillas and will prolong the model’s lifespan. BPA-free products are, no doubt, the best options.

Ease of Use

Quesadilla makers are pretty elementary to use, but there are models that offer a few modern features that others don’t. You want to choose a model that is easy to operate. Easy to see buttons and clear instructions should come with the product. Other models come with a free recipe book that’s very helpful for beginners.

Maintenance

A lot of ingredients can ooze out when cooking your quesadillas, cheese, sauces, and grease can be quite a challenge to clean. Therefore, it’s better to get a model that offers non-stick surfaces and drip trays.

What Can You Make in a Quesadilla Maker? 

Out of all the kitchen appliances available in the market, I am sure that the quesadilla maker is a favorite of a lot of people. It does not take too much space in the kitchen, and you have almost unlimited ways to use it.

Quesadilla makers are, of course, designed to make delicious quesadillas, but did you know you can make a lot more dishes with it?

These are only some of the savory and sweet dishes your children will definitely enjoy:

  • Pizzadillas
  • Grilles Cheese Sandwiches
  • Bbanana and peanut butter pancakes
  • Appledillas
  • Crepes

How Do You Clean a Quesadilla Maker?  

If you’re like me, I can sometimes play around with different ingredients to fill my quesadillas. Of course, I use a lot of cheese, and I admit that I use more than enough, which makes it ooze out. Other than that, grease and sauces can also ooze out from the quesadilla pockets.

That said, we have to clean our quesadilla makers after we use it for safety and hygienic purposes. No one wants to use an appliance with a lot of leftover food and bacteria, right?

Maintaining the cleanliness of our quesadillas will also ensure that it will continue to function properly. So, how do you clean it? Just follow these steps:

  1. First, prepare your dish towels, paper towels, and a soft-bristle brush. Place the appliance on top of the towel so you won’t make a mess.
  2. Plug the appliance for a while, just to heat it a little bit. When hot, place two wet paper towels inside and close it for a few minutes. This should make the remaining food soft and easy to remove.
  3. Using a soft bristle brush, scrub the crannies and grooves gently. Wipe every inch dry before storing.

And that’s it! Pretty easy, right? Now, you have no excuse in not cleaning your quesadilla makers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here we have the most commonly asked queries regarding the best quesadilla makers:

1. How long will it take to fully cook a quesadilla?

The cooking time depends on the composition of the ingredients and how thick your quesadillas are. Generally, it ranges from only 3 to five minutes. Leaving it for more than 5 minutes might make the fillings overflow or burn.

2. Which type of tortilla can I use for an electric quesadilla maker? 

You can use both flour tortilla and corn tortilla, whichever you prefer. Just be sure to follow the right procedures in using your electric quesadilla maker.

3. What are the common ingredients you can use for your quesadilla filling?

You can use whatever kind of cheese, leftover meats, salsa, and pepper. And you can also use shrimp!

4. Should I use oil in making quesadilla?

If you have a model that has a non-stick coating, oil is not really needed. But a little bit of oil will not hurt. It will make it easier to release your quesadilla from the machine, and it will also give the quesadilla a crispier and more golden-brown finish.

5. Can I freeze my quesadilla if I want to eat it later?

Yes! After you cook it, let it cool down completely and wait for it to be firm before you place it in the freezer. Be sure to store it in a clean plastic bag, and you can freeze it for up to two months.

Final Words

That’s it! We hope this quesadilla maker review helped you. For sure, you already know everything you need to cook those delicious quesadillas. The only thing left to do it to purchase the best quesadilla maker for you. Good luck, and enjoy cooking!

Leave a Comment